← Browse neighborhoods
Cheap beer in Gramercy
Gramercy is a small, settled neighborhood and it drinks like one — Third Avenue pubs, a couple of genuinely old taverns including the oldest continuously operating bar in the city, and very little that is new or loud. The price range is narrow, which is unusual: there is no dive tier below and no rooftop tier above. Happy hour is where the neighborhood is more interesting than it looks, with several long weekday windows running from the early afternoon and at least one bar running a late-evening window instead of an afternoon one.
8 priced bars tracked · lowest listed price $7.00 · middle listed price $7.00 · 5 with published happy-hour details. These prices are a starting point, not identical-pour comparisons: a listing may be a can, bottle, or draft. Check the note and source before traveling, especially for a time-limited special.
Bars with listed beer prices
Barfly
$7.00
244 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
Official drink menu lists Michelob Ultra at $7, Stella and Modelo at $9, and several other drafts/cans at $10.
Source: Barfly official drink menu
Fitzgerald's Pub
$7.00
336 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010
$7 pints / $21 pitchers of house Fitzgerald's Amber & Lager.
Source: fitzgeraldspub.nyc home page
Seven Sins Bar
$7.00
293 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
The official drinks menu lists Bud, Bud Light, Miller High Life, and Michelob Ultra at $7. Select drafts are $7 during weekday happy hour.
Happy hour: Mon–Fri · 16:00–19:00 · $7.00
Source: Seven Sins official drinks menu
Whiskey Roxx
$7.00
239 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10003, USA
Cheapest regularly-available beers are $7 each: Bud Light (draft or can/bottle), Coors Light, Michelob Ultra, and Budweiser, per the official page.
Source: Whiskey Roxx official menu page
Pete's Tavern
$8.00
129 E 18th St, New York, NY 10003, USA
Cheapest regular beer found: Pete's 1864 House Ale, Pete's Easy Light Lager, Michelob Ultra, or Bud Light. Happy-hour times are posted, but beer discount/price is not explicit.
Source: Pete's Tavern official beer and wine menu
Pete's Tavern
$8.00
129 E 18th St, New York, NY 10003
Oldest continuously operating bar/restaurant in NYC (1864). Cheapest drafts: Pete's 1864 House Ale & Pete's "Easy" Light Lager, both $8.
Source: Pete's Tavern - official beer & wine menu
Bar Calico
$9.00
23 Lexington Ave 2nd floor, New York, NY 10010, USA
Cheapest regularly-available beer is $9, a tie between Modelo Especial (bottle/can) and Angry Orchard hard cider (can). Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA is also $9. Other regular options: Pacifico $10, Peroni $10, Charro $11. Separately, Bar Calico runs a 'Late Night Happy Hour' Monday-Saturday from 9PM until close, during which Peroni draft beer is $7 -- this is a verified recurring happy-hour price, not the cheapest regular-menu price.
Happy hour: Mon–Wed · 21:00–00:00 · $7.00 | Thu · 21:00–01:00 · $7.00 | Fri–Sat · 21:00–02:00 · $7.00
Source: Bar Calico official menu page
Paul & Jimmy’s of Gramercy
$9.00
123 E 18th St, New York, NY 10003, USA
Cheapest regularly-available beer is $9, tied among all six bottled beers on the official website's Birra (Beer) list (Dogfish 90 Min IPA, Heineken, Peroni, Guinness, Amstel Light, Brooklyn East India Pale Ale) — no draft beer is offered. Strongbow Cider ($10) is excluded as it is not a beer, and Buckler ($9) is excluded as non-alcoholic.
Source: Paul & Jimmy's of Gramercy official website — Food Menu (Birra section)
Using this list
For a live, distance-aware view from where you are, open the map. To compare neighborhoods or see the rest of our coverage, visit the full bar directory. See how we collect and rank listing information and how to compare beer prices fairly.
21 of 21 tracked listings in this area include a public source or source label. Prices and availability can change; call ahead when it matters.